I felt that my own country had taken a wrong turn

Guantanamo’s innocuous men By Mahvish Khan, Special to The Washington Post

[Ali Shah] Mousovi is a physician from the Afghan city of Gardez, where he was arrested by U.S. troops 2 1/2 years ago. He tells us that he had returned to Afghanistan in August 2003, after 12 years of exile in Iran, to help rebuild his wathan, his homeland. He believes that someone turned him in to U.S. forces just to collect up to $25,000 being offered to anyone who gave up a Talib or al Qaeda member.

As I translate from Pashto, Mousovi hesitantly describes life since his arrest. Transported to the Bagram air base near Kabul in eastern Afghanistan, he was thrown — blindfolded, hooded and gagged — into a 3 1/2 -by-7-foot shed. He says he was beaten regularly by Americans in civilian clothing, deprived of sleep by tape-recordings of sirens that blared day and night. He describes being dragged around by a rope, subjected to extremes of heat and cold. He says he barely slept for an entire month.

He doesn’t know why he was brought to Guantanamo Bay. He had hoped he would be freed at his military hearing in December 2004. Instead, he was accused of associating with the Taliban and of funneling money to anti-coalition insurgents. When he asked for evidence, he was told it was classified. And so he sits in prison, far from his wife and three children. More than anyone, he misses his 11-year-old daughter, Hajar. When he talks about her, his eyes fill with tears, and his head droops. …

The very existence of the military detention camp at Guantanamo Bay seemed an affront to what the United States stands for. How could our government deny the prisoners there the right to a fair hearing? I didn’t know whether they were innocent or guilty — but I figured they should be entitled to the same protections as any rape or murder suspect. …

As an American, I felt the pain of Sept. 11, and I understood the need to invade Afghanistan and destroy the Taliban and al Qaeda. But I also felt the suffering of the Afghans as their country was bombed. And when hundreds of men were rounded up and thrust into a black hole of detention, many with seemingly no proof that they had any terrorist connections, I felt that my own country had taken a wrong turn. …

No matter the age or background of the detainee, our meetings always leave me feeling helpless. These men show me the human face of the war on terrorism. They’ve been systematically dehumanized, cast as mere numbers in prison-camp fashion. But to me, they’ve become almost like friends, or brothers or fathers. I can honestly say that I don’t believe any of our clients are guilty of crimes against the United States. No doubt some men here are, but not the men I’ve met. …

Most are held in isolation in cells separated by thick steel mesh or concrete walls. Every man eats every meal alone in his small cell. The prisoners are allowed out of their cells three times a week for about 15 minutes to exercise, often in the middle of the night, so many don’t see sunlight for months at a time.

mjh’s blog — Another Victim of American Torture: Maher Arar

mjh’s blog — America kidnapped me

Meet a Terrorist Suspect

Guantanamo’s innocuous men By Mahvish Khan, Special to The Washington Post

At 80, Haji Nusrat — Detainee No. 1009 — is Guantanamo Bay’s oldest prisoner. A stroke 15 years ago left him partly paralyzed. He cannot stand up without assistance, and he hobbles to the bathroom behind a walker. Despite his paralysis, his swollen legs and feet are tightly cuffed and shackled to the floor. He says that his shoes are too tight and that he needs new ones. He has asked for medical attention for the inflammation in his legs but has not been taken to a hospital.

“They wait until you are almost dead,” he says.

He has a long white beard and grayish-brown eyes that drift from Peter’s face to mine as we explain his legal issues to him. In the middle of our meeting, he says to me: “Bachay.” My child. “Look at my white beard. They have brought me here with a white beard. I have done nothing at all. I have not said a single word against the Americans.”

He comes from a small mountain village in Afghanistan and cannot read or write. He has 10 children and does not know if his wife is still alive — he hasn’t received any letters.

U.S. troops arrested Nusrat in 2003, a few days after he went to complain about the arrest of his son Izat, who also is detained at Guantanamo Bay.

As I read this article, I could hear Donald Rumsfeld’s voice intoning, “they’re trained to lie!” I wonder what training Rummy had or if he’s just a natural. Is solitary confinement really the best way to handle an 80 year old man, liar or not? mjh

For All Junkies, the Next Score is the Most Important

Since Congress is dragging it’s feet on addressing our country’s shortage on oil, I have made a bumper sticker I think we should get out to everyone to get this back on the front burner. I am attaching the simple design with a PDF. I am willing to make and sell these to anyone who wants one. All I ask is a $5 donation to go to help fund conservative, logical thinking congressmen’s campaigns across the nation. For each $5 political contribution, I will donate the profit of $2.50 each to a candidates that are Pro-Anwar drilling.

Thanks…. I enjoy your blog….

Kim

Well, this is certainly a different tone from Jeff’s recent comment. I do have to wonder if Kim has ever read my blog.

Kim’s bumpersticker says “Drill ANWR” and features a giant drill bit. I take that to mean “screw everything” — whether intended or not.

The ANWR obsession is particularly strange. First, ANWR was part of a earlier compromise — you get to destroy this big area, we get to keep this small area. So, now non-conserving Conservatives are proud to be known as unwilling to stand by previous agreements? Or is this just a flip-flop?

Second, if drilling were approved tomorrow, how long before oil from ANWR morphed into gas in your tank? I’ve heard 10 years, but let’s just say that’s exaggerated. Five years? In five years, the price per gallon will be well over $5.

Finally, at least among enviro-whackos, the potential output from ANWR is predicted to be relatively small compared to our bottomless thirst. Doesn’t it seem that in 5 to 10 years we could set our sights on saving more than ANWR would ever pump?

It should be clear to everyone: we will not drill our way out of this hole. mjh

Brave New Education

ABQjournal: Letters to the Editor
Brave New Education

I WAS DELIGHTED to read the story about the drug searches at Rio Rancho High School. The value of this educational opportunity is incalculable. It is absolutely essential that our young adult students understand the importance of these exercises.

Not only do they learn the importance of obedience to the law, they also now have a better understanding of law enforcement’s need to do warrantless searches and seizures whenever there is the slightest chance that drugs might be involved.

They also received valuable instruction in the need for quiet, unquestioning obedience to all dictates of anyone in authority. We are preparing these students for life in the 21st century. All citizens will need special training in these concepts as the new police state emerges.

JOE GABEL
Albuquerque

Bravo, Joe.

The Radical Right speaks constantly about “respect for the law” even as they push laws, like South Dakota’s abortion ban, that neither respect precedent nor the citizens. The Radical Right can’t stand all those “illegals” demanding — demanding! — rights. The Radical Right can’t stand the courts, where reasoning has standards, evidence and proof — those damn unelected activist judges; those frivolous lawsuits. The Radical Right hates government, compromise and nuance but loves obedience to absolute authority (the bible). The Radical Right clings to a dim-witted strongman who feels free to interpret all laws any way he sees fit. We’re one terrorist attack from martial law.

Just shut up, get in line, and do what the men in uniform tell you to do — or else! mjh

PS: As an aside, sarcasm is tricky in writing or verbally. Some never get it; some hate it. In the same section, I think Gary didn’t handle it quite as deftly as Joe, though he makes his point even so.

Drought Does Not Compute Continue reading Brave New Education

War is No Bargain

Independent Online Edition > Americas
Iraq war set to be more expensive than Vietnam
By Rupert Cornwell in Washington
Published: 28 April 2006

The Iraq war has already cost the United States $320bn (£180bn), according to an authoritative new report, and even if a troop withdrawal begins this year, the conflict is set to be more expensive in real terms than the Vietnam War, a generation ago.

The estimate, circulated this week by the non-partisan Congressional Research Service (CRS), can only increase unease over the US presence in Iraq, whose direct costs now run at some $6bn a month, or $200m a day, with no end in sight.

That’s a full $2.2 billion since this article was published. Well, that’s inflation for you.

The real war loonies will quote figures on deaths. Many of today’s battlefield injuries would have been fatal 40 years ago. How long before the number of seriously wounded surpasses Vietnam? Don’t expect anyone to tell you.

I still seethe that the Radical Right jumped all over Kerry/Edwards for “lying” that the war’s cost was $200 Billion. Lying? It was a gross underestimate. mjh

Missed News: Rummy’s Tamiflu Profits

Anyone will tell you, ‘Republicans are good for business.’ Especially for their own, it seems. I’ve already suggested the main campaign slogan for 2006 should be:

Republicans Mean Business

But I’m starting to appreciate Newt Gingrich’s own suggestion:

Had enough?

mjh

PS: Ask someone in the MSM how this could not be news in the US?

Independent Online Edition > Americas
Donald Rumsfeld makes $5m killing on bird flu drug
By Geoffrey Lean and Jonathan Owen
Published: 12 March 2006

Donald Rumsfeld has made a killing out of bird flu. The US Defence Secretary has made more than $5m (£2.9m) in capital gains from selling shares in the biotechnology firm that discovered and developed Tamiflu, the drug being bought in massive amounts by Governments to treat a possible human pandemic of the disease.

More than 60 countries have so far ordered large stocks of the antiviral medication – the only oral medicine believed to be effective against the deadly H5N1 strain of the disease – to try to protect their people. The United Nations estimates that a pandemic could kill 150 million people worldwide.

Daily Times – Site Edition
Donald Rumsfeld makes $5m from bird flu drug

Tamiflu does not cure the disease, but if taken soon after symptoms appear it can reduce its severity. The drug was developed by a Californian biotech company, Gilead Sciences. It is now made and sold by the giant chemical company Roche, which pays it a royalty on every tablet sold, currently about a fifth of its price.

Rumsfeld was on the board of Gilead from 1988 to 2001, and was its chairman from 1997. He then left to join the Bush administration, but retained a huge shareholding.

The firm made a loss in 2003, the year before concern about bird flu started. Then revenues from Tamiflu almost quadrupled, to $44.6m, helping put the company well into the black. Sales almost quadrupled again, to $161.6m last year. During this time the share price trebled.

Rumsfeld sold some of his Gilead shares in 2004 reaping – according to the financial disclosure report he is required to make each year – capital gains of more than $5m. The report showed that he still had up to $25m-worth of shares at the end of 2004, and at least one analyst believes his stake has grown well beyond that figure, as the share price has soared. Further details are not likely to become known, however, until Rumsfeld makes his next disclosure in May.

Rumsfeld Gilead – Google News (at this writing, only 6 news articles — these are the only 2 about this investment — none in the US)

Gilead — Donald H. Rumsfeld Named Chairman of Gilead Sciences
Foster City, CA, January 3, 1997

Back in the World

Last Wednesday, I woke up feeling a bit blah. I’ll spare you the details of what we euphemistically call “stomach flu,” but my condition deteriorated rapidly from there. Soon, my whole world contracted to two spaces: my bed and the bathroom. Before long, taking care of myself meant laying immobile for as long as I could, listening with curiosity to my own ragged grunts. I’m not whining; I’ve been sicker and know people in far worse conditions. But, I was more than sick enough, thank you very much.

For days, I had thunderstorms in the arroyos of my guts. They raged from left to right and back again. I sounded like a giant jug knocked on its side, contents burbling out.

Completely drained and wrung out, my worst symptoms stopped and I was left in this limbo of “relatively better.” I measured progress in sitting up for a few minutes longer. I watched more TV than usual — some of the stuff I saw on KNME was so lovely it helped me a bit: pictures of New Mexico and Utah set to classical music and poetic narration. I saw a video I want to loop in my final hours.

I can’t say that I thought a lot that is worth remembering. But I did think about loss of capacity; about being unable to decide for oneself; being so dependent on others.

I thought about aging and the struggle between acceptance and resistance to many things that may be inevitable in spite of our resistance or made so by our acceptance. I’ve come no closer to wisdom.

I thought about god and the atheist’s dilemma in not having anyone to blame or beg. Thankfulness is a different matter — it doesn’t require a recipient.

Being an optimist and not THAT sick, I knew I would recover in time, even after a few false starts. Today, 5 full days after the onset, I feel the best I have since this began, though still weak. I finally *want* food — interesting food. I want to photograph flowers. I want to write. I want a haircut! mjh

haircut
photo and haircut by MRudd